James Livesay was christened on 24 July 1785 in Redfields, Darwin, Lancashire, England.¹ He was the son of James Livesay and Betty Nuttal.¹

     Betty Livesay was christened on 11 July 1786 in Darwin, Lancashire, England.¹ She was the daughter of James Livesay and Betty Nuttal.¹

     Richard Livesay was christened on 7 October 1787 in Darwin, Lancashire, England.¹ He was the son of James Livesay and Betty Nuttal.¹

     Richard Livesay was christened on 1 January 1789 in Darwin, Lancashire, England.¹ He was the son of James Livesay and Betty Nuttal.¹

     Ellen Livesay was christened on 16 May 1789 in Sough, Darwin, Lancashire, England.¹ She was the daughter of James Livesay and Betty Nuttal.¹

     Betty Livesay was christened on 23 June 1790 in Punstock, Darwin, Lancashire, England.¹ She was the daughter of James Livesay and Betty Nuttal.¹

     Henry Winger was born on 19 March 1803 in Hempfield Township, Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania.^2,3 He was the son of John Winger and Christina Mary Miller.¹ He was baptized on 14 April 1803 in Harrold Zion Lutheran Congregation, Hempfield Township, Westmoreland County.² He married Sarah Fry, daughter of John Adam Fry and Margaret (?), on 26 July 1821 in Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania.⁴ He died on 24 December 1864 in Cornplanter Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, at age 61.⁵

     Henry Winger is head of household in the 1830 Census of Hempfield Township, Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania.⁶ He appears on the tax lists for Beaver Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, in 1834. He was taxed for 1 cow. (Beaver Township became part of Clarion County in 1839.)⁷ He appears on the tax lists for Cranberry Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, in 1839. He was taxed for 1 cow; however, in 1840, Henry was taxed for 100 acres. The last year he is listed on the Cranberry Township tax lists was 1850.⁸ He was living in Cranberry Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, in 1850.⁹ He appears on the tax lists for President Township, Venango County, between 1851 and 1858. He is taxed for between 100 and 150 acres until 1854 when the tax list shows that Henry property had been sold to I. Evans. That same year, Henry's brother Peter apparently sold his 100 acres to Henry. Henry apparently sold 25 acres of that land by 1856 and sold the remaining 75 acres to a Mr. Bleakley in 1858. The tax lists show that Henry had moved to Cornplanter Township by 1857. He remained there until his death.^10,11 He was living in Cornplanter Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, in 1860.¹² He was a farmer.^9,12

     Daniel Winger was born on 31 July 1805 in Hempfield Township, Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania.^2,3 He was the son of John Winger and Christina Mary Miller.¹ He was baptized on 15 September 1805 in Harrold Zion Lutheran Congregation, Hempfield Township, Westmoreland County.² He married Anna Delo, daughter of George Michael Delo.^4,5,6 He married Sarah Stover.^7,8

     Daniel Winger was a farmer, first in Beaver Township, Clarion County, Pennsylvania, but later in Elk Township, Clarion County.^9,10,7,11,12 He was living in Elk Township, Clarion County, Pennsylvania, in 1880 with his son Joseph.¹³

     David Winger was born on 25 September 1807 in Hempfield Township, Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania.^2,3,4 He was the son of John Winger and Christina Mary Miller.¹ He was baptized on 10 November 1807 in Harrold Zion Lutheran Congregation, Hempfield Township, Westmoreland County.² He married Catherine Smith, daughter of John Smith and Barbara Sellers, in 1832 in Clarion County, Pennsylvania.^5,6 He died on 17 December 1862 in Cornplanter Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, at age 55.^7,8,9 He was buried in Mt. Zion Cemetery, Shippenville, Elk Township, Clarion County, Pennsylvania.³

     David Winger was living in Cornplanter Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, in 1850.¹⁰ He was living in Piney Township, Clarion County, Pennsylvania, in 1860.¹¹ He was a blacksmith.^10,11 He and Catherine Smith were the parents of 11 children, seven of whom were living in 1888.¹²

     Mary Ann Winger was born on 4 January 1814 in Hempfield Township, Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania.^2,3 She was the daughter of John Winger and Christina Mary Miller.¹ She was baptized on 13 March 1814 in First Lutheran Church, Greensburg, Westmoreland County. Jacob and Anna Maria Winger served as sponsors at the baptism.² She married Henry Mohnkern.⁴ She died on 9 March 1873 in Siverly, Cornplanter Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, at age 59.^4,5 She was buried in Grove Hill Cemetery, Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania.⁶

     Mary Ann Winger and Henry Mohnkern were living in Beaver Township, Clarion County, Pennsylvania, in 1850.⁷

     Peter Winger was born on 20 July 1827 in Beaver Township, Clarion County, Pennsylvania.^2,3,4 He was the son of John Winger and Christina Mary Miller.¹ He was baptized on 2 September 1827 in St. Paul's Lutheran Church, Beaver Township, Clarion County, Pennsylvania.¹ He married Ann Lamb.^3,5,6 He died on 22 February 1886 in Wilmington Township, Mercer County, Pennsylvania, at age 58.⁷

     Peter Winger and Ann Lamb were living with Peter's parents in Cranberry Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, in 1850.³ He and Ann Lamb were living in Cornplanter Township, Venango County, in 1860.⁸ He and Ann Lamb moved to Wilmington Township, Mercer County, Pennsylvania, by 1870 and remained there the rest of their lives.^9,10

     Josephine Carson was born on 14 April 1842 in Armstrong County, Pennsylvania.¹ She was the daughter of George Washington Carson and Rhoda Mitchell.² She married William Henry Beatty, son of Francis Beatty and Mary Donahey, on 28 November 1863 in Sunville, Plum Township, Venango County.¹ She died on 30 June 1878 in Edensburg (now Knox), Beaver Township, Clarion County, Pennsylvania, at age 36.¹

     As heirs of Francis Beatty, William Henry Beatty, his wife Josephine, Nancy Agnes Beatty, her husband Gilbert Sanner, Mary Ann Beatty, her husband James M. McMillen, and Francis C. Beatty sold Francis Beatty's 111 acres farm in Jackson Township, Venango County, to William Frazier of Sugarcreek Township, Venango County for $500 to each of Francis' children.³

     George Washington Carson married Rhoda Mitchell.¹

     Rhoda Mitchell married George Washington Carson.¹

     Jacob Sanner was born circa 1772 in Pennsylvania.^1,2 He married Margaret (?)^1,2 He died circa 1866 in Jackson Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania.³

     Jacob Sanner was living in Point Township, Northumberland County, Pennsylvania, as early as 1818.^4,5 He purchased 103 acres and 72 perches in Point Township on 21 July 1818 from Marks John Biddle, Esq. of Reading, Berks County, Pennsylvania for $602.52.⁴ He and Margaret (?) sold the 103 acres in Point Township on 13 May 1839 to Charles Parks.⁶
     Jacob Sanner moved from Northumberland County to Canal Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, by 1840.⁷ He purchased 50 acres in Canal Township, Venango County, on 3 April 1849 from John and Anna Adams of Fairfield Township, Crawford County for $800. It appears that Jacob was paying taxes on this land as early as 1841 when he moved to Venango County.^{8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15} He and Margaret sold the 50 acres in Canal Township on 9 April 1849 to John Luper and Henry Kelley of Canal Township for $900.¹⁶ Following the sale of the 50 acres, Jacob Sanner continued to live in Canal Township.¹⁷ He appeared on the tax lists for Canal Township from 1852 to 1859. He was taxed for 15 acres of land in 1852, and 14 acres of land until 1857. For 1859, the last year he appeared on the Canal Township tax lists, he was only taxed for 1 cow.^{18,19,20,21,22,23,24}
     Jacob Sanner was living in Jackson Township, Venango County, by 1858 when he first appears on the Jackson Township tax lists. Between 1863 and 1866, Jacob was taxed for 22 to 25 acres of land. His trade was listed as farmer. He apparently spent the rest of his life in Jackson Township.^25,26,27,28 Jacob and Margaret purchased 50 acres in Canal Township, Venango County, on 11 March 1859 from John and Margaret Bleakley of Jackson Township for $255.50. The deed was recorded on 27 July 1865. This land appear to have been on the border of Canal and Jackson Townships and is probably the same property that he was paying taxes on in Jackson Township.^29,30 The 25 acres of land in Jackson Township assessed to his son Gilbert Sanner in 1865 was probably land that originally belonged to Jacob.³¹ Jacob Sanner was taxed for 25 acres in Jackson Township in 1866. This is the last time that Jacob appears in the Jackson Township assessment lists.³²

     Margaret (?) was born circa 1800 in Pennsylvania.³ She married Jacob Sanner.^1,2 She died on 26 August 1876 in Poor House, Sugarcreek Township, Venango County.⁴

     Margaret (?) and Jacob Sanner sold the 103 acres in Point Township on 13 May 1839 to Charles Parks.⁵ She and Jacob Sanner sold the 50 acres in Canal Township on 9 April 1849 to John Luper and Henry Kelley of Canal Township for $900.⁶ Margaret and Jacob purchased 50 acres in Canal Township, Venango County, on 11 March 1859 from John and Margaret Bleakley of Jackson Township for $255.50. The deed was recorded on 27 July 1865. This land appear to have been on the border of Canal and Jackson Townships and is probably the same property that he was paying taxes on in Jackson Township.^7,8 Margaret Sanner is head of household in the 1870 Census of Canal Township, Venango County. According to the census enumeration she was 69 years old, born in Pennsylvania, and had no occupation.³

     George Sanner was born circa 1839 in Pennsylvania.^4,1,2,3 He was the son of Jacob Sanner and Margaret (?)^1,2,3 He married Harriet Beatty, daughter of John Beatty and Mary McCurdy.⁵ He died in August 1869 in Jackson Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania.^1,2,3

     George Sanner was taxed for 1 cow in Canal Township in 1862.⁶ George Sanner was taxed for 1 cow in Canal Township between 1863 and 1864. A notation in the assessment list states that George was a laborer.⁷ George Sanner was taxed for 2 horses and 1 horned cow in Canal Township in 1865.⁸ George Sanner was taxed for 25 acres in Jackson Township in 1867.⁹ George Sanner was taxed for 25 acres in Jackson Township in 1868.¹⁰ George Sanner was taxed for 25 acres in Jackson Township in 1869.¹¹

     John Sanner was taxed for 1 cow in Canal Township, Venango County, in 1841. This is the first entry for John Sanner in the assessment lists for Canal Township.¹ John Sanner was taxed for 1 cow in Canal Township in 1842. This is the last time John appears in the Canal Township assessment lists.² George Sanner was taxed for 1 cow in Canal Township in 1862.³ George Sanner was taxed for 1 cow in Canal Township between 1863 and 1864. A notation in the assessment list states that George was a laborer.⁴ George Sanner was taxed for 2 horses and 1 horned cow in Canal Township in 1865.⁵

     John Sanner was taxed for 100 acres, 2 horses, and 1 cow in Jackson Township in 1847. His trade is listed as miller.¹ John Sanner was taxed for 100 acres and 2 horses in Jackson Township in 1847.² John Sanner was taxed for 2 horses and 2 cows in Jackson Township in 1848.³ John Sanner was taxed for 100 acres, 1 horse, and 3 cows in Jackson Township in 1849.⁴ John Sanner was taxed for no land in Jackson Township in 1850. His trade is listed as Miller.⁵ John Sanner was taxed for 1 horse and 1 cow in Jackson Township in 1851.⁶ John Sanner Jr. was taxed for 1 horse in Jackson Township in 1851.⁷ John Sanner was taxed for 2 horses and 1 cow in Jackson Township in 1852.⁸ John Sanner Jr. was taxed for 2 horses and 1 cow in Jackson Township in 1852. It was noted that he was available for the militia.⁹ John Sanner was taxed for 2 horses and 2 cows in Jackson Township in 1853.¹⁰ John Sanner was taxed for 2 horses and cows in Jackson Township in 1854.¹¹ John Sanner was listed in the 1856 assessment lists for Jackson Township but not assessed for any property.¹² John Sanner was taxed for 2 horses and 2 cows in Jackson Township in 1857.¹³ John Sanner was taxed for 1 cow in Jackson Township in 1858.¹⁴ Gilbert Sanner was taxed for 25 acres in Jackson Township in 1865. This land was probably conveyed to Gilbert by his father Jacob Sanner. The piece of property continued to be taxed to Gilbert's heirs following his death.¹⁵ Jacob Sanner was taxed for 25 acres in Jackson Township in 1866. This is the last time that Jacob appears in the Jackson Township assessment lists.¹⁶ Francis C. Beatty was taxed for his occupation in Jackson Township, Venango County, in 1866.¹⁷ George Sanner was taxed for 25 acres in Jackson Township in 1867.¹⁸ George Sanner was taxed for 25 acres in Jackson Township in 1868.¹⁹ George Sanner was taxed for 25 acres in Jackson Township in 1869.²⁰

     John Sanner was born circa 1800 in Pennsylvania.¹ He was the son of Jacob Sanner. He married Catherine (?)² He died on 9 July 1870 in Mecca Township, Trumbull County, Ohio.³ He was buried in East Mecca Cemetery, Mecca Township.³

     John Sanner was listed as the head of a family on the 1840 Census of Canal Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania.⁴ John Sanner was taxed for 1 cow in Canal Township, Venango County, in 1841. This is the first entry for John Sanner in the assessment lists for Canal Township.⁵ John Sanner was taxed for 1 cow in Canal Township in 1842. This is the last time John appears in the Canal Township assessment lists.⁶ John Sanner was taxed for 100 acres, 2 horses, and 1 cow in Jackson Township in 1847. His trade is listed as miller.⁷ John Sanner was taxed for 100 acres and 2 horses in Jackson Township in 1847.⁸ John Sanner was taxed for 2 horses and 2 cows in Jackson Township in 1848.⁹ John Sanner was taxed for 100 acres, 1 horse, and 3 cows in Jackson Township in 1849.¹⁰ John Sanner was taxed for no land in Jackson Township in 1850. His trade is listed as Miller.¹¹ He was listed as the head of a family on the 1850 Census of Jackson Township, Venango County. The household consisted of J. Sanner 50 [John]; C. 45 [Catherine]; R. 18 [Reuben]; J. 11; J. 10; S. 7 (f); J. 4 [Jacob].¹² John Sanner was taxed for 1 horse and 1 cow in Jackson Township in 1851.¹³ John Sanner was taxed for 2 horses and 1 cow in Jackson Township in 1852.¹⁴ John Sanner was taxed for 2 horses and 2 cows in Jackson Township in 1853.¹⁵ John Sanner was taxed for 2 horses and cows in Jackson Township in 1854.¹⁶ John Sanner was listed in the 1856 assessment lists for Jackson Township but not assessed for any property.¹⁷ John Sanner was taxed for 2 horses and 2 cows in Jackson Township in 1857.¹⁸ John Sanner was taxed for 1 cow in Jackson Township in 1858.¹⁹ He was listed as the head of a family on the 1860 Census of Sugarcreek Township, Venango County. The household consisted of John Sanner, 59; Catherine, 55; Jacob, 14.²⁰ He and Catherine (?) were living in Mecca Township, Trumbull County, Ohio, in 1870.²¹

     John Sanner Jr. was born on 1 September 1829 in Sunbury, Northumberland County, Pennsylvania.³ He was the son of John Sanner and Catherine (?)^1,2 He married Deborah Turner, daughter of David Turner and Elizabeth Atwood, on 30 November 1848.^3,4 He died on 25 February 1901 in Tionesta, Forest County, Pennsylvania, at age 71.³

     John Sanner Jr. was taxed for 1 horse in Jackson Township in 1851.⁵ John Sanner Jr. was taxed for 2 horses and 1 cow in Jackson Township in 1852. It was noted that he was available for the militia.⁶ He and Deborah Turner were living in Allegheny Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, in 1860.⁷ He and Deborah Turner were living in Cornplanter Township, Venango County, in 1880.⁸ He and Deborah Sanner moved to Tionesta, Forest County, Pennsylvania, in April 1881.^3,4,9

     Robert Beatty was born between 1756 and 1765.^2,3,4,5 He married Agnes Calhoun.^1,6 He died on 16 May 1823 in Sugarcreek Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania.^1,5 He was buried in Shaw Farm Cemetery, Sugarcreek Township.⁷

     It is not known where Robert Beatty was born. The 1890 Venango County history states that he came from one of the eastern counties of Pennsylvania.¹⁰
     The earliest known record of Robert and Agnes is the 1790 Census for Northumberland County, Pennsylvania. The household likely consisted of Robert, Agnes, their 3 daughters Sarah, Mary Ann, and Nancy and son John. In 1790, Northumberland County was a sprawlling county stretching from the East Branch of the Susquehanna River on the east to the Allegheny River in the west, and from the New York state line in the north to the West Branch of the Susquehanna to the south. It is difficult to narrow down where in the massive county Robert was living. However, family tradition says that Robert's son John was born on the West Branch of the Susquehanna River in 1788. This would suggest that Robert and his family were living on the north side of the West Branch in the area that is now part of Lycoming, Clinton, and Clearifeld Counties. Further it is possible that our Robert is the same as Robert Beatty who appears on the tax lists of Pine Creek Township, Northumberland County in 1787. This Robert Beaty is assessed for one cow and no land. Pine Creek which runs through Pine Creek Township is a tributary of the West Branch.^11,12,13
     Robert and Agnes settled in what would become Sugarcreek Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, in April 1797 according to a deposition that Robert signed as part of the land warrant application he submitted in 1806.^14,15 Robert received a land grant along with a Mr. Oliver Ormsby, a merchant from Pittsburgh, in Sugarcreek Township dated 27 October 1806. This grant was for 400 acres of land Robert had settled upon, as described above. He paid $53.90 for the tract. According to his application, Robert had built a nineteen foot square house that was one and a half stories high. He also had a barn and stable. He had at least 20 acres of land cleared and cultivated with "several crops of wheat, rye, corn, oats, and grasses."¹⁴ Oliver Ormsby was a weathly businessman in Pittsburgh and land speculator in western Pennyslvania. He most likely entered into the land grant with Robert in exchange for a portion of the land. In 1822, Ormsby deeded 150 acres of the 400 acres land grant to Robert for $1.^16,17
     Robert received a land grant for 169 acres "situated on the waters of Sugar Creek" in Sugarcreek Township on 5 April 1814. Robert paid $20 per hundered acres plus interest from March 1801.¹⁸
     Robert's name appears on ledgers of trading posts operated by George Power and Edward Hale prior to 1800 in the settlement located where the city of Franklin in Venango County now stands. George Power's ledger is dated 1794 to 1800 while Hale's ledger spans 1798 to 1800.¹⁹
     Robert and Agnes are said to have been the first settlers in the Sugar Creek valley and the first within the limits of what is now in Jackson Township, Venango County. The specific location of their settlement was where Sugar Creek crosses from Sugarcreek Borough into Jackson Township, south of modern-day Cooperstown. However, this area was located within Sugarcreek Township until the formation of Jackson Township in 1845. As described in the 1890 Venango County history, at that location, "the valley of the stream is fully half a mile wide. The channel of the creek is near the bluffs on the east leaving a level expanse of meadows with a gradual slope from the west. At an early date this was called 'the prairie.' It was not covered by a dense forest like the surrounding country but merely with an thick growth of underbrush, and was readily reduced to cultivation."^20,2,3,4
     Robert first appears on the tax assessment lists for Sugarcreek Township in 1806 which was the first year assessments were made in the recently established Venango County. He was assessed to have a total of 450 acres, 1 horse, 1 ox, and cow that year. While the amount of land he was taxed for varied between 100 and 250 acres over the years he lived in Sugarcreek Township, at the time of his death in 1823, Robert was assessed for 300 acres.²¹
     He served as supervisor of Sugarcreek Township in 1804 and 1805 and in 1806 served on a grand jury for Venango County.²²
     Robert and Agnes were Presbyterians and where among the original members of the Sugar Creek Presbyterian Church, one of the oldest denominational organizations in western Pennsylvania. Robert was to have given four acres for a church and graveyard.²³ He was associated with the Democrat Party.⁸
     Robert left a will dated 27 December 1822 in Venango County. According to the will, which was entered into probate on 22 May 1823, one third of Robert's estate was for his "beloved wife" Nancy. His sons Frances and Robert were to divide his real estate and receive a horse, saddle and bridle, and one gun each. His daughters Mary and Jane where to receive one dollar while sons John and Samuel and daughter Nancy already received $40, $50, and $16 respectively. Daughter Sarahan, Elizabeth, Isabella, Ann, and Lilah were to receive equal shares of his personal estate.²⁴ An inventory for Robert's estate was filed on 18 January 1823. According to the inventory, his personal estate was worth $776.51.²⁵

     Agnes Calhoun was born circa 1766 in Pennsylvania.^3,2,4 She married Robert Beatty.^3,2 She died after 1850.^3,2

     The earliest known record of Robert and Agnes is the 1790 Census for Northumberland County, Pennsylvania. The household likely consisted of Robert, Agnes, their 3 daughters Sarah, Mary Ann, and Nancy and son John. In 1790, Northumberland County was a sprawlling county stretching from the East Branch of the Susquehanna River on the east to the Allegheny River in the west, and from the New York state line in the north to the West Branch of the Susquehanna to the south. It is difficult to narrow down where in the massive county Robert was living. However, family tradition says that Robert's son John was born on the West Branch of the Susquehanna River in 1788. This would suggest that Robert and his family were living on the north side of the West Branch in the area that is now part of Lycoming, Clinton, and Clearifeld Counties. Further it is possible that our Robert is the same as Robert Beatty who appears on the tax lists of Pine Creek Township, Northumberland County in 1787. This Robert Beaty is assessed for one cow and no land. Pine Creek which runs through Pine Creek Township is a tributary of the West Branch.^5,6,7
     Agnes and Robert settled in what would become Sugarcreek Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, in April 1797 according to a deposition that Robert signed as part of the land warrant application he submitted in 1806.^8,9
     Agnes and Robert are said to have been the first settlers in the Sugar Creek valley and the first within the limits of what is now in Jackson Township, Venango County. The specific location of their settlement was where Sugar Creek crosses from Sugarcreek Borough into Jackson Township, south of modern-day Cooperstown. However, this area was located within Sugarcreek Township until the formation of Jackson Township in 1845. As described in the 1890 Venango County history, at that location, "the valley of the stream is fully half a mile wide. The channel of the creek is near the bluffs on the east leaving a level expanse of meadows with a gradual slope from the west. At an early date this was called 'the prairie.' It was not covered by a dense forest like the surrounding country but merely with an thick growth of underbrush, and was readily reduced to cultivation."^10,11,12,4
     Agnes and Robert were Presbyterians and where among the original members of the Sugar Creek Presbyterian Church, one of the oldest denominational organizations in western Pennsylvania. Robert was to have given four acres for a church and graveyard.¹³
     Agnes Beatty, her daughter Elizabeth and the children of her deceased son Francis were living in Jackson Township, Venango County, in 1850.¹⁴

     Elizabeth Beatty was born circa 1801 in Sugarcreek Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania.¹ She was the daughter of Robert Beatty and Agnes Calhoun.¹

     Elizabeth Beatty was unmarried and living with her mother Agnes Beatty and the children of her deceased brother Francis in 1850 in Jackson Township, Venango County.¹ She and her nephew Samuel Beatty were living in Canal Township, Venango County, in 1860.² She was living in Williamsfield, Ashtabula County, Ohio, in 1870 in the household of a James Kelley. James Kelley was probably her nephew, son of her sister Mary Ann. Also living with her was George F. Sanner, her great-nephew, son of Nancy Beatty Sanner McMillen.³ She was living in Girard Township, Erie County, Pennsylvania, in 1880 again with James Kelley, who was probably her nephew.⁴

     Gene Humphrey Kennedy married Lou Ann Swift, daughter of Shirley Lou Hoffman, on 24 June 1978.¹

     Shane Paul Kennedy is the son of Gene Humphrey Kennedy and Lou Ann Swift.¹

     Sabrina Lynn Kennedy is the daughter of Gene Humphrey Kennedy and Lou Ann Swift.¹

     Catherine (?) was born circa 15 April 1805 in Northampton County, Pennsylvania.¹ She married John Sanner, son of Jacob Sanner.¹ She died on 8 March 1882 in Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania.¹ She was buried in West Maca, Ohio.¹

     Catherine (?) and John Sanner were living in Mecca Township, Trumbull County, Ohio, in 1870.²

     Deborah Turner was born on 25 July 1823 near New York.^3,1 She was the daughter of David Turner and Elizabeth Atwood.² She married John Sanner Jr., son of John Sanner and Catherine (?), on 30 November 1848.^4,1 She died on 14 January 1908 in Tionesta, Forest County, Pennsylvania, at age 84.¹ She was buried in Riverside Cemetery, Tionesta, Forest County.¹

     Deborah Turner and John Sanner Jr. were living in Allegheny Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, in 1860.⁵ She and John Sanner Jr. were living in Cornplanter Township, Venango County, in 1880.⁶ She and John Sanner Jr. moved to Tionesta, Forest County, Pennsylvania, in April 1881.^4,1,7

     Reuben Sanner was born on 18 August 1832 in Pennsylvania.¹ He was the son of John Sanner and Catherine (?)¹ He married Nancy (?)² He married Henrietta J. Barr circa 1888.³ He died on 18 December 1914 in Oil City, Venango County, at age 82.¹ He was buried in Bethel Cemetery, Oakland Township, Venango County.¹

     Reuben Sanner and Nancy (?) were living in Allegheny Township, Venango County, in 1860.⁴ He served in the Grand Army of the Republic during the Civil War. He enlisted as a private in Company E, Ohio 177th Infantry Regiment on 28 September 1864. He mustered out on 24 Jun 1865 at Greensboro, North Carolina.⁵ He and Nancy (?) were living in Mecca Township, Trumbull County, Ohio, between 1870 and 1880.^2,6 He and Henrietta J. Barr were living in Jackson Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, in 1900.^3,7