Speaking of Family... - Person Page

Sarah Yates¹

b. 16 March 1822, d. 7 August 1909

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Sarah Yates was born on 16 March 1822.¹ She married Charles Benninghoff, son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.¹ She died on 7 August 1909 at age 87.¹ She and Charles Benninghoff were buried in Shenango Valley Cemetery, Greenville, Mercer County.¹

Family

Charles Benninghoff b. 18 Jul 1828, d. 10 Mar 1890

Children

Sylvester Benninghoff+^1,2 b. 27 Nov 1850, d. 6 Oct 1926
George Acquila Benninghoff³ b. c 1851
Margaret A. Benninghoff+¹ b. 1851, d. 1938
Lyman Marcus Benninghoff⁴ b. 10 Dec 1862, d. 4 Jun 1921

Citations

[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998). Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , from Paul Dentler. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."
[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". . Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."
[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , from Mary F. Christian, Orland, CA. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."

Martin Benninghoff¹

b. 16 March 1828, d. 3 March 1898

Father

John Benninghoff¹ b. 27 Oct 1801, d. 20 Mar 1882

Mother

Elizabeth Heise¹ b. 5 Nov 1804, d. 26 Jul 1872

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Martin Benninghoff was born on 16 March 1828 in Clearfield County.¹ He was the son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.¹ He married Anna Mary Gahring on 10 October 1855.² He died on 3 March 1898 in Mercer County at age 69.¹ He and Anna Mary Gahring were buried in Shenango Valley Cemetery, Greenville, Mercer County.¹

Family

Anna Mary Gahring b. 12 Sep 1826, d. 26 Oct 1892

Children

Martin L. Benninghoff+^1,2 b. 31 Aug 1856, d. 1926
George H. Benninghoff¹ b. 1857, d. 1931
Jacob G. Benninghoff+³ b. 13 May 1859, d. 3 Mar 1898
Anna E. Benninghoff³ b. c 1860, d. young
Julia A. Benninghoff+¹ b. 16 May 1862, d. 17 Feb 1905
John M. Benninghoff+¹ b. 15 Feb 1864, d. 21 Aug 1908
Joseph L. Benninghoff+¹ b. 1866, d. 1942
Frederick W. Benninghoff¹ b. 1868, d. 1930
Jeremiah B. Benninghoff+¹ b. 1870, d. 1933

Citations

[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998). Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S190] Unknown author, History of Mercer County, Pennsylvania (n.p.: n.pub., 1888), p. 1168.
[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , from Dorothy Kilpatrick. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."

Anna Mary Gahring¹

b. 12 September 1826, d. 26 October 1892

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Anna Mary Gahring was born on 12 September 1826 in Trabugen, Germany.¹ She married Martin Benninghoff, son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise, on 10 October 1855.² She died on 26 October 1892 in Mercer County at age 66.¹ She and Martin Benninghoff were buried in Shenango Valley Cemetery, Greenville, Mercer County.¹

Family

Martin Benninghoff b. 16 Mar 1828, d. 3 Mar 1898

Children

Martin L. Benninghoff+^1,2 b. 31 Aug 1856, d. 1926
George H. Benninghoff¹ b. 1857, d. 1931
Jacob G. Benninghoff+³ b. 13 May 1859, d. 3 Mar 1898
Anna E. Benninghoff³ b. c 1860, d. young
Julia A. Benninghoff+¹ b. 16 May 1862, d. 17 Feb 1905
John M. Benninghoff+¹ b. 15 Feb 1864, d. 21 Aug 1908
Joseph L. Benninghoff+¹ b. 1866, d. 1942
Frederick W. Benninghoff¹ b. 1868, d. 1930
Jeremiah B. Benninghoff+¹ b. 1870, d. 1933

Citations

[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998). Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S190] Unknown author, History of Mercer County, Pennsylvania (n.p.: n.pub., 1888), p. 1168.
[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , from Dorothy Kilpatrick. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."

Amelia Benninghoff¹

b. 25 December 1830, d. 28 March 1882

Father

John Benninghoff¹ b. 27 Oct 1801, d. 20 Mar 1882

Mother

Elizabeth Heise¹ b. 5 Nov 1804, d. 26 Jul 1872

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Amelia Benninghoff was born on 25 December 1830 in Cherrytree Township, Venango County.¹ She was the daughter of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.¹ She married Jacob Gahring on 31 August 1859 in Venango County.² She died on 28 March 1882 in Mercer County at age 51.¹ She and Jacob Gahring were buried in Shenango Valley Cemetery, Greenville, Mercer County.¹

Family

Jacob Gahring b. 4 Dec 1824, d. 1890

Citations

[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998). Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S190] Unknown author, History of Mercer County, Pennsylvania (n.p.: n.pub., 1888), p. 1179.

Jacob Gahring¹

b. 4 December 1824, d. 1890

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Jacob Gahring was born on 4 December 1824 in Wurtenburg, Germany.¹ He married Amelia Benninghoff, daughter of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise, on 31 August 1859 in Venango County.² He died in 1890 in Mercer County.¹ He and Amelia Benninghoff were buried in Shenango Valley Cemetery, Greenville, Mercer County.¹

Family

Amelia Benninghoff b. 25 Dec 1830, d. 28 Mar 1882

Citations

[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998). Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S190] Unknown author, History of Mercer County, Pennsylvania (n.p.: n.pub., 1888), p. 1179.

Elizabeth Benninghoff¹

b. 3 September 1832, d. 21 November 1909

Father

John Benninghoff¹ b. 27 Oct 1801, d. 20 Mar 1882

Mother

Elizabeth Heise¹ b. 5 Nov 1804, d. 26 Jul 1872

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Elizabeth Benninghoff was born on 3 September 1832 in Cherrytree Township, Venango County.¹ She was the daughter of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.¹ She married Robert Sprowl Howe, son of Samuel Howe and Sarah Sprowl, on 2 March 1854.² She died on 21 November 1909 in Greenville, Mercer County, at age 77.¹ She and Robert Sprowl Howe were buried in Shenango Valley Cemetery, Greenville, Mercer County.¹

Family

Robert Sprowl Howe b. 25 Jun 1834, d. 18 Jul 1917

Children

Citations

[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998). Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S190] Unknown author, History of Mercer County, Pennsylvania (n.p.: n.pub., 1888), p. 1181, biographical sketch of Robert S. Howe.

Robert Sprowl Howe¹

b. 25 June 1834, d. 18 July 1917

Father

Mother

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Robert Sprowl Howe was born on 25 June 1834 in Pithole, Venango County.¹ He was the son of Samuel Howe and Sarah Sprowl.² He married Elizabeth Benninghoff, daughter of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise, on 2 March 1854.² He died on 18 July 1917 in Jamestown, Mercer County, at age 83.¹ He and Elizabeth Benninghoff were buried in Shenango Valley Cemetery, Greenville, Mercer County.¹

Family

Elizabeth Benninghoff b. 3 Sep 1832, d. 21 Nov 1909

Children

Citations

[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998). Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S190] Unknown author, History of Mercer County, Pennsylvania (n.p.: n.pub., 1888), p. 1181, biographical sketch of Robert S. Howe.

Catherine Benninghoff¹

b. circa 1833, d. 9 April 1883

Father

John Benninghoff¹ b. 27 Oct 1801, d. 20 Mar 1882

Mother

Elizabeth Heise¹ b. 5 Nov 1804, d. 26 Jul 1872

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Catherine Benninghoff was born circa 1833 in Cherrytree Township, Venango County.¹ She was the daughter of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.¹ She married Horace Franklin Drake, son of Benjamin Drake and Almira Barnard.¹ She died on 9 April 1883.¹

Family

Horace Franklin Drake b. 7 Sep 1828

Citations

[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , unknown source. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."

Horace Franklin Drake¹

b. 7 September 1828

Father

Benjamin Drake² b. 1 Oct 1804, d. 22 Apr 1884

Mother

Almira Barnard² b. 15 Jul 1804, d. 12 Dec 1881

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Horace Franklin Drake was born on 7 September 1828 in Norwich, Massachusetts.² He was the son of Benjamin Drake and Almira Barnard.² He married Catherine Benninghoff, daughter of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.¹

Family

Catherine Benninghoff b. c 1833, d. 9 Apr 1883

Citations

[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , unknown source. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."
[S1185] Nicki Austin, "Descendants of John Drake", 5 Aug 1999 (Rt. 3, Box 36, L'ville, IL 62439). Copy provided by Janet Durst Sweet, Palo Alto, CA, no sources.

John E. Benninghoff¹

b. 7 October 1835, d. 11 March 1888

Father

John Benninghoff¹ b. 27 Oct 1801, d. 20 Mar 1882

Mother

Elizabeth Heise¹ b. 5 Nov 1804, d. 26 Jul 1872

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

John E. Benninghoff was born on 7 October 1835 in Cherrytree Township, Venango County.¹ He was the son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.¹ He married Anna Gahring.² He died on 11 March 1888 in Hempfield Township, Mercer County, at age 52.^1,2 He and Anna Gahring were buried in Shenango Valley Cemetery, Greenville, Mercer County.¹

Family

Anna Gahring b. 16 Apr 1842, d. 27 Jan 1908

Citations

[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998). Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S8] Obituary of John E. Benninghoff, The Oil City Derrick, Oil City, PA, (unknown date) 1888, Oil City Library, Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania, ((also Venango Spectator, 22 Mar 1888, Franklin, PA)). Hereinafter cited as The Derrick.

Anna Gahring¹

b. 16 April 1842, d. 27 January 1908

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Anna Gahring was born on 16 April 1842.¹ She married John E. Benninghoff, son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.² She died on 27 January 1908 in Mercer County at age 65.¹ She and John E. Benninghoff were buried in Shenango Valley Cemetery, Greenville, Mercer County.¹

Family

John E. Benninghoff b. 7 Oct 1835, d. 11 Mar 1888

Citations

[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998). Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S8] Obituary of John E. Benninghoff, The Oil City Derrick, Oil City, PA, (unknown date) 1888, Oil City Library, Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania, ((also Venango Spectator, 22 Mar 1888, Franklin, PA)). Hereinafter cited as The Derrick.

Frederick W. Benninghoff¹

b. 31 July 1837, d. 15 March 1907

Father

John Benninghoff¹ b. 27 Oct 1801, d. 20 Mar 1882

Mother

Elizabeth Heise¹ b. 5 Nov 1804, d. 26 Jul 1872

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Frederick W. Benninghoff was born on 31 July 1837 in Cherrytree Township, Venango County.¹ He was the son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.¹ He married Frances Jane Ricketts in 1859.² He died on 15 March 1907 in Greenville, Mercer County, at age 69.¹ He and Frances Jane Ricketts were buried in Shenango Valley Cemetery, Greenville, Mercer County.¹

Family

Frances Jane Ricketts b. 10 Sep 1841, d. 1920

Children

Mary Emeline Benninghoff¹ b. 9 Aug 1860, d. 26 Nov 1958
Nancy Elizabeth Benninghoff³ b. 4 Oct 1861, d. 16 Aug 1905
Effie J. Benninghoff^4,2 b. 1867
W. Sherman Benninghoff⁴
Mary May Benninghoff⁵ b. 1869
Ora Luella Benninghoff¹ b. 8 Jan 1869, d. 24 Mar 1869
Nerr Benninghoff¹ b. 1870, d. 26 Feb 1875
Jerry Fred Benninghoff⁶ b. 17 Feb 1872, d. 24 Aug 1892
Blanche Benninghoff¹ b. 29 May 1873, d. 10 Sep 1946
Frances Annie Pearl Benninghoff⁷ b. Nov 1880
Catherine Edna Amelia Benninghoff⁷ b. Jan 1883, d. 1959
Blaine Benninghoff^1,4,7 b. Aug 1883 or 1884, d. 1952
Logan Benninghoff⁸ b. 26 Jun 1886, d. Mar 1965

Citations

[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998). Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S192] Unknown author, History of Mercer County, PA (n.p.: n.pub., 1909).
[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998), p. 118. Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S154] Frederick W. Benninghoff Will, Venango County Will Docket (unknown citation), Registrar & Recorder's Office, Courthouse, Franklin, Venango County, Pennsylvania.
[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , unknown source. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."
[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998), p. 53. Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S207] 1910 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Mercer Co., Greenville, household of Frederick W. Benninghoff, National Archives.
[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , Social Security Death Index. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."

Frances Jane Ricketts^1,2

b. 10 September 1841, d. 1920

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Frances Jane Ricketts was born on 10 September 1841 in Venango County.^1,2 She married Frederick W. Benninghoff, son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise, in 1859.² She died in 1920 in Mercer County.^1,2 She and Frederick W. Benninghoff were buried in Shenango Valley Cemetery, Greenville, Mercer County.¹

Family

Frederick W. Benninghoff b. 31 Jul 1837, d. 15 Mar 1907

Children

Mary Emeline Benninghoff¹ b. 9 Aug 1860, d. 26 Nov 1958
Nancy Elizabeth Benninghoff³ b. 4 Oct 1861, d. 16 Aug 1905
Effie J. Benninghoff^2,4 b. 1867
W. Sherman Benninghoff⁴
Mary May Benninghoff⁵ b. 1869
Ora Luella Benninghoff¹ b. 8 Jan 1869, d. 24 Mar 1869
Nerr Benninghoff¹ b. 1870, d. 26 Feb 1875
Jerry Fred Benninghoff⁶ b. 17 Feb 1872, d. 24 Aug 1892
Blanche Benninghoff¹ b. 29 May 1873, d. 10 Sep 1946
Frances Annie Pearl Benninghoff⁷ b. Nov 1880
Catherine Edna Amelia Benninghoff⁷ b. Jan 1883, d. 1959
Blaine Benninghoff^4,1,7 b. Aug 1883 or 1884, d. 1952
Logan Benninghoff⁸ b. 26 Jun 1886, d. Mar 1965

Citations

[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998). Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S192] Unknown author, History of Mercer County, PA (n.p.: n.pub., 1909).
[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998), p. 118. Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S154] Will of Frederick W. Benninghoff Will, Venango County Will Docket, Registrar & Recorder's Office, Courthouse, Franklin, Venango County, Pennsylvania.
[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , unknown source. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."
[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998), p. 53. Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S207] 1910 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Mercer Co., Greenville, household of Frederick W. Benninghoff, National Archives.
[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , Social Security Death Index. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."

Jeremiah Benninghoff¹

b. 31 May 1841, d. 3 April 1903

Father

John Benninghoff¹ b. 27 Oct 1801, d. 20 Mar 1882

Mother

Elizabeth Heise¹ b. 5 Nov 1804, d. 26 Jul 1872

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Jeremiah Benninghoff was born on 31 May 1841 in Cherrytree Township, Venango County.¹ He was the son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.¹ He married Wilhelmina Haas on 9 May 1872.¹ He died on 3 April 1903 in Greenville, Mercer County, at age 61.¹

Family

Wilhelmina Haas b. 18 Mar 1850

Citations

[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , Information from Dorothy Kilpatrick. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."

Wilhelmina Haas¹

b. 18 March 1850

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Wilhelmina Haas was born on 18 March 1850.¹ She married Jeremiah Benninghoff, son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise, on 9 May 1872.¹

Family

Jeremiah Benninghoff b. 31 May 1841, d. 3 Apr 1903

Citations

[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , information from Dorothy Kilpatrick. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."

Mary Jane Benninghoff¹

b. circa 1840, d. 18 January 1898

Father

John Benninghoff¹ b. 27 Oct 1801, d. 20 Mar 1882

Mother

Elizabeth Heise¹ b. 5 Nov 1804, d. 26 Jul 1872

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Mary Jane Benninghoff was born circa 1840 in Cherrytree Township, Venango County.¹ She was the daughter of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.¹ She married Elias Reep on 22 August 1861.¹ She died on 18 January 1898 in Fairview, Butler County, Pennsylvania.¹ She and Elias Reep were buried in Bear Creek Cemetery, Fairview, Butler County.¹

Family

Elias Reep b. 14 Jun 1832, d. 1912

Citations

[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , Information from Reynold Reep. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."

Elias Reep¹

b. 14 June 1832, d. 1912

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Elias Reep was born on 14 June 1832 in Fairview, Butler County, Pennsylvania.¹ He married Mary Jane Benninghoff, daughter of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise, on 22 August 1861.¹ He died in 1912 in Fairview, Butler County.¹ He and Mary Jane Benninghoff were buried in Bear Creek Cemetery, Fairview, Butler County.¹

Family

Mary Jane Benninghoff b. c 1840, d. 18 Jan 1898

Citations

[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , Information from Reynold Reep. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."

Joseph Benninghoff¹

b. 18 December 1843, d. 10 March 1924

Father

John Benninghoff¹ b. 27 Oct 1801, d. 20 Mar 1882

Mother

Elizabeth Heise¹ b. 5 Nov 1804, d. 26 Jul 1872

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Joseph Benninghoff was born on 18 December 1843 in Cherrytree Township, Venango County.¹ He was the son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.¹ He married Ella Affantranger on 4 December 1868 in Meadville, Crawford County, by Rev. Isaac Bennehoff.² He married Jennie Miller on 14 December 1898?³ He died on 10 March 1924 in Mercer County at age 80.¹ He and Ella Affantranger were buried in Shenango Valley Cemetery, Mercer County.¹

Joseph Benninghoff was listed as the head of a family on the 1900 Census of Greenville, Mercer County, Pennsylvania. The household consisted of Joseph, his wife Jennie, and Joseph's children Josephine, Hellen, and Arthur A.⁴ He was listed as the head of a family on the 1910 Census of Greenville, Mercer County, Pennsylvania. The household consisted of Joseph Benninghoff, 65, window, no occupation; Leon A., 33 single; Josephine, 28, md 5y, widow, 1 child/1lvg; Elizabeth, 7; Mary Ellen, 3/12, grand dau.⁵

Family 1

Ella Affantranger b. 25 May 1848, d. 15 Apr 1899

Children

Maud Benninghoff+^1,6 b. 24 Aug 1869, d. 1937
Arthur H. Benninghoff⁶
Leon A. Benninghoff⁶ b. c 1877
Josephine Benninghoff+⁷ b. Mar 1882
Helen M. Benninghoff^7,6 b. Oct 1886, d. Dec 1965

Family 2

Jennie Miller b. Sep 1864, d. 14 Feb 1903

Child

Elizabeth B. Benninghoff⁶ b. c 1903

Citations

[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998). Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S193] Marriage announcement of Joseph Benninghoff and Ella Affantranger, Crawford Democrat, Meadville, PA, 7 Nov. 1868, Crawford County Historical Society, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Crawford Democrat.
[S192] Unknown author, History of Mercer County, PA (n.p.: n.pub., 1909), pp. 431-2.
[S152] 1900 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Mercer Co., Greenville, Joseph Benninghoff household, National Archives, (Joseph Benninghoff, Dec 1843, 56y, PA, md. 34 yrs; Jennie, Sep 1864, 35y, no children; Josephine, Mar 1882, 18; Hellen, Oct 1886, 13; Arthur A., May 1890, 10).
[S207] 1910 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Mercer Co., Greenville, Joseph Benninghoff household, National Archives.
[S192] Unknown author, History of Mercer County, PA (n.p.: n.pub., 1909), pp. 430-431.
[S152] 1900 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Mercer Co., Greenville, household of Joseph Benninghoff, National Archives.

Ella Affantranger¹

b. 25 May 1848, d. 15 April 1899

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Ella Affantranger was born on 25 May 1848 in Meadville, Crawford County.¹ She married Joseph Benninghoff, son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise, on 4 December 1868 in Meadville, Crawford County, by Rev. Isaac Bennehoff.² She died on 15 April 1899 in Mercer County at age 50.¹ She and Joseph Benninghoff were buried in Shenango Valley Cemetery, Mercer County.¹

Family

Joseph Benninghoff b. 18 Dec 1843, d. 10 Mar 1924

Children

Maud Benninghoff+^1,3 b. 24 Aug 1869, d. 1937
Arthur H. Benninghoff³
Leon A. Benninghoff³ b. c 1877
Josephine Benninghoff+⁴ b. Mar 1882
Helen M. Benninghoff^4,3 b. Oct 1886, d. Dec 1965

Citations

[S135] Mark S. Painter, Shenango Valley Cemetery, Book 1, 1882-1913 (Apollo, PA: Closson Press, 1998). Hereinafter cited as Shenango Valley Cemetery.
[S193] Marriage announcement of Joseph Benninghoff and Ella Affantranger, Crawford Democrat, Meadville, PA, 7 Nov. 1868, Crawford County Historical Society, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Crawford Democrat.
[S192] Unknown author, History of Mercer County, PA (n.p.: n.pub., 1909), pp. 430-431.
[S152] 1900 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Mercer Co., Greenville, household of Joseph Benninghoff, National Archives.

Jennie Miller¹

b. September 1864, d. 14 February 1903

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Jennie Miller was born in September 1864.^1,2 She married Joseph Benninghoff, son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise, on 14 December 1898?¹ She died on 14 February 1903 at age 38.¹ She was buried in Riverside Cemetery, Sharpsville, Mercer County.³

Family

Joseph Benninghoff b. 18 Dec 1843, d. 10 Mar 1924

Child

Elizabeth B. Benninghoff⁴ b. c 1903

Citations

[S192] Unknown author, History of Mercer County, PA (n.p.: n.pub., 1909), pp. 431-2.
[S152] 1900 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Mercer Co., Greenville, Joseph Benninghoff household, National Archives.
[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , gravestone, Riverside Cemetery. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."
[S192] Unknown author, History of Mercer County, PA (n.p.: n.pub., 1909), pp. 430-431.

Milton Benninghoff¹

b. circa 1845, d. 11 February 1909

Father

John Benninghoff¹ b. 27 Oct 1801, d. 20 Mar 1882

Mother

Elizabeth Heise¹ b. 5 Nov 1804, d. 26 Jul 1872

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Milton Benninghoff was born circa 1845.¹ He was the son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.¹ He married Julia Holmes.¹ He died on 11 February 1909.¹

Family

Citations

[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , unknown source. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."

Julia Holmes¹

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Julia Holmes married Milton Benninghoff, son of John Benninghoff and Elizabeth Heise.¹

Family

Milton Benninghoff b. c 1845, d. 11 Feb 1909

Citations

[S191] Charlotte Blair Stewart, "Benninghoff Notes". , unknown source. Hereinafter cited as "Charlotte's Benninghoff Notes."

Nancy (?)¹

b. circa 1810

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Nancy (?) was born circa 1810 in Pennsylvania.¹ She married Philip Benninghoff, son of Frederick Benninghoff and Maria Elizabeth Wert.¹

Family

Philip Benninghoff b. c 1803, d. 22 Mar 1877

Children

Mary Benninghoff²
John Benninghoff¹ b. c 1830, d. c Nov 1852
Sarah Benninghoff+^1,2 b. c 1832
Susannah Benninghoff^1,2 b. c 1834
Henry Benninghoff^1,3 b. 1839
Levi Benninghoff^1,2 b. c 1842
Lavina Benninghoff^1,2 b. c 1846
Ellen Jane Benninghoff^2,1 b. c 1848

Citations

[S137] 1850 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Clearfield Co., Boggs Tp., Philip Benninghoff household, National Archives.
[S195] Clearfield County Will, unknown repository, unknown repository address . Hereinafter cited as Clearfield Co. Will.
[S131] Mary Joyce Penticoff and Randolph Ray, Descendants of Albert Benighoff (Rockton, IL: M.J. Penticoff, 1995), p. 30.

Mary Benninghoff¹

Father

Philip Benninghoff¹ b. c 1803, d. 22 Mar 1877

Mother

Nancy (?)² b. c 1810

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Mary Benninghoff was the daughter of Philip Benninghoff and Nancy (?)^1,2 She married (?) Louden before 1850.¹

Family

Citations

[S195] Philip Benninghoff will, Clearfield County Will WB B:453, dated 13 Apr. 1877, unknown repository, unknown repository address . Hereinafter cited as Clearfield Co. Will.
[S195] Clearfield County Will, unknown repository, unknown repository address . Hereinafter cited as Clearfield Co. Will.

(?) Louden¹

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

(?) Louden married Mary Benninghoff, daughter of Philip Benninghoff and Nancy (?), before 1850.¹

Family

Mary Benninghoff

Citations

[S195] Philip Benninghoff will, Clearfield County Will WB B:453, dated 13 Apr. 1877, unknown repository, unknown repository address . Hereinafter cited as Clearfield Co. Will.

John Benninghoff¹

b. circa 1830, d. circa November 1852

Father

Philip Benninghoff¹ b. c 1803, d. 22 Mar 1877

Mother

Nancy (?)¹ b. c 1810

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

John Benninghoff was born circa 1830.¹ He was the son of Philip Benninghoff and Nancy (?)¹ He died circa November 1852 in Boggs Township, Clearfield County.²

Citations

[S137] 1850 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Clearfield Co., Boggs Tp., Philip Benninghoff household, National Archives.
[S194] John Benninghoff estate papers, Clearfield County probate records, Registrar's Docket (unknown citation), unknown repository, unknown repository address, Letters of Administration grated 4 Dec 1852 to Philip Benehoof and John Stiles. Hereinafter cited as Clearfield Co. probate records.

Sarah Benninghoff^1,2

b. circa 1832

Father

Philip Benninghoff^1,2 b. c 1803, d. 22 Mar 1877

Mother

Nancy (?)^1,3 b. c 1810

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Sarah Benninghoff was born circa 1832.^1,2 She was the daughter of Philip Benninghoff and Nancy (?)^1,2,3 She married Lee Mease.^4,2

Family

Child

Clara Mease²

Citations

[S137] 1850 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Clearfield Co., Boggs Tp., Philip Benninghoff household, National Archives.
[S195] Philip Benninghoff will, Clearfield County Will WB B:453, dated 13 Apr. 1877, unknown repository, unknown repository address . Hereinafter cited as Clearfield Co. Will.
[S195] Clearfield County Will, unknown repository, unknown repository address . Hereinafter cited as Clearfield Co. Will.
[S131] Mary Joyce Penticoff and Randolph Ray, Descendants of Albert Benighoff (Rockton, IL: M.J. Penticoff, 1995), p. 30.

Lee Mease^1,2

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Lee Mease married Sarah Benninghoff, daughter of Philip Benninghoff and Nancy (?).^1,3

Family

Sarah Benninghoff b. c 1832

Child

Clara Mease²

Citations

[S131] Mary Joyce Penticoff and Randolph Ray, Descendants of Albert Benighoff (Rockton, IL: M.J. Penticoff, 1995), p. 30.
[S195] Clearfield County Will, unknown repository, unknown repository address . Hereinafter cited as Clearfield Co. Will.
[S195] Philip Benninghoff will, Clearfield County Will WB B:453, dated 13 Apr. 1877, unknown repository, unknown repository address . Hereinafter cited as Clearfield Co. Will.

Susannah Benninghoff^1,2

b. circa 1834

Father

Philip Benninghoff^1,2 b. c 1803, d. 22 Mar 1877

Mother

Nancy (?)^1,3 b. c 1810

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Susannah Benninghoff was born circa 1834.^1,2 She was the daughter of Philip Benninghoff and Nancy (?)^1,2,3 She married Hamilton Graffius.^4,2

Family

Hamilton Graffius

Citations

[S137] 1850 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Clearfield Co., Boggs Tp., Philip Benninghoff household, National Archives.
[S195] Philip Benninghoff will, Clearfield County Will WB B:453, dated 13 Apr. 1877, unknown repository, unknown repository address . Hereinafter cited as Clearfield Co. Will.
[S195] Clearfield County Will, unknown repository, unknown repository address . Hereinafter cited as Clearfield Co. Will.
[S131] Mary Joyce Penticoff and Randolph Ray, Descendants of Albert Benighoff (Rockton, IL: M.J. Penticoff, 1995), p. 30.

Hamilton Graffius^1,2

Charts

Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff

Hamilton Graffius married Susannah Benninghoff, daughter of Philip Benninghoff and Nancy (?).^1,3

Family

Susannah Benninghoff b. c 1834

Citations

[S131] Mary Joyce Penticoff and Randolph Ray, Descendants of Albert Benighoff (Rockton, IL: M.J. Penticoff, 1995), p. 30.
[S195] Phillip Benninghoff will, Clearfield County Will WB B:453, dated 13 Apr. 1877, unknown repository, unknown repository address . Hereinafter cited as Clearfield Co. Will.
[S195] Philip Benninghoff will, Clearfield County Will WB B:453, dated 13 Apr. 1877, unknown repository, unknown repository address . Hereinafter cited as Clearfield Co. Will.