Esther Dean was born on 26 March 1915 in Franklin, Venango County, Pennsylvania.¹ She married Charles Edward Fenstermaker, son of Daniel Webster Fenstermaker and Harriet Celestrial Pierce.¹ She died on 11 June 1965 in Oil City, Venango County, at age 50.¹

     Rose Elizabeth Fenstermaker was born on 21 June 1906 in Kingsley Township, Forest County, Pennsylvania.^1,2 She was the daughter of Daniel Webster Fenstermaker and Harriet Celestrial Pierce.¹ She married Lionel Clarence Oakes on 1 May 1923.³ She died in March 1978 in Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania, at age 71.²

     Lionel Clarence Oakes was born on 18 October 1902 in Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania.¹ He married Rose Elizabeth Fenstermaker, daughter of Daniel Webster Fenstermaker and Harriet Celestrial Pierce, on 1 May 1923.¹ He died on 16 July 1974 in Sugarcreek Borough, Venango County, Pennsylvania, at age 71.¹ He was buried in Lamey Cemetery, Oakland Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania.¹

     Leon Carbaugh was born circa 1902 in Forest County, Pennsylvania.¹ He was the son of William H. Carbaugh and Alice Mae Pierce.¹ He died between 1910 and 1920.^1,2

     Chester W. Carbaugh was born on 16 January 1908 in Pennsylvania.^1,2 He was the son of William H. Carbaugh and Alice Mae Pierce.¹ He died on 27 July 1990 in Pennsylvania at age 82.²

     Bertha M. Carbaugh was born on 10 February 1910 in Kingsley Township, Forest County, Pennsylvania.^1,2 She was the daughter of William H. Carbaugh and Alice Mae Pierce.¹ She married Victor McDonald.³ She died on 3 January 1997 in Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania, at age 86.²

     Victor McDonald married Bertha M. Carbaugh, daughter of William H. Carbaugh and Alice Mae Pierce.¹

     Harry L. Carbaugh was born circa 1919 in Pennsylvania.¹ He was the son of William H. Carbaugh and Alice Mae Pierce.¹ He died between 1920 and 1930 in Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania.^1,2

     Henry Leroy Carbaugh was born on 2 October 1905 in Buck Mills, Forest County, Pennsylvania.^1,2 He was the son of William H. Carbaugh and Alice Mae Pierce.¹ He married Helen Cubitt on 23 July 1928.¹ He died on 9 February 1995 in Brookville, Jefferson County, Pennsylvania, at age 89.¹ He was buried in Brandon Cemetery, Cranberry Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania.¹

     Henry Leroy Carbaugh was known as Roy.

     Helen Cubitt married Henry Leroy Carbaugh, son of William H. Carbaugh and Alice Mae Pierce, on 23 July 1928.¹

     Forest Junior Carbaugh was born on 26 May 1915 in Tionesta, Forest County, Pennsylvania.^1,2 He was the son of William H. Carbaugh and Alice Mae Pierce.¹ He married Alice Hawks on 3 December 1935 in Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania.¹ He died on 10 July 1946 in Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania, at age 31.¹

     Alice Hawks married Forest Junior Carbaugh, son of William H. Carbaugh and Alice Mae Pierce, on 3 December 1935 in Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania.¹

     Robert K. Carbaugh was born on 9 April 1921 in Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania.^1,2 He was the son of William H. Carbaugh and Alice Mae Pierce.¹ He married Hope M. Summerville on 6 September 1947 in Oil City, Venango County.¹ He died on 26 June 1993 in Oil City, Venango County, at age 72.¹

     Hope M. Summerville married Robert K. Carbaugh, son of William H. Carbaugh and Alice Mae Pierce, on 6 September 1947 in Oil City, Venango County.¹

     Alvie James Harkins was born on 9 September 1913 in Pennsylvania.^2,1 He was the son of James Eli Harkins and Sadie Althea Pierce.¹ He died on 30 July 1991 in Youngsville, Warren County, Pennsylvania, at age 77.¹

     Mary Evelyn Harkins was born on 5 July 1916 in Pennsylvania.^1,2,3 She was the daughter of James Eli Harkins and Sadie Althea Pierce.¹ She was unmarried.^2,3 She died on 8 January 2002 in Youngsville, Warren County, Pennsylvania, at age 85.³

     Mary Evelyn Harkins also went by the name of Evelyn.²

     Isabelle Marie Harkins was born on 13 April 1918 in Pennsylvania.^1,2 She was the daughter of James Eli Harkins and Sadie Althea Pierce.¹ She died in 1924.²

     Hazel Sadie Harkins was born on 17 December 1919 in Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania.^1,2 She was the daughter of James Eli Harkins and Sadie Althea Pierce.¹ She died in 1920.^2,1

     Garvin Edward Harkins was born on 27 January 1930 in Pennsylvania.¹ He was the son of James Eli Harkins and Sadie Althea Pierce.¹ He died circa March 1930.¹

     Russell Howard Harkins was born on 6 December 1914 in Kellettville, Forest County, Pennsylvania.^1,2 He was the son of James Eli Harkins and Sadie Althea Pierce.¹ He married Dorothy L. George.³ He died on 29 June 1982 in Erie, Erie County, Pennsylvania, at age 67.² He was buried in Laural Hill Cemetery, Erie.²

     Dorothy L. George was born on 3 April 1917 in St. Charles.¹ She married Russell Howard Harkins, son of James Eli Harkins and Sadie Althea Pierce.¹ She died on 29 November 1964 in Erie, Erie County, Pennsylvania, at age 47.¹ She was buried in Laural Hill Cemetery, Erie.¹

     James Gordon Harkins was born on 12 November 1924 in Pennsylvania.^1,2 He was the son of James Eli Harkins and Sadie Althea Pierce.¹ He died on 10 November 1978 in Pittsfield Township, Warren County, Pennsylvania, at age 53.² He was buried in Riverside Cemetery, Tionesta, Forest County, Pennsylvania.³

     James Gordon Harkins served in the U.S. Army during World War II.²

     Charles Lawrence Harkins was born on 16 November 1925 in Pennsylvania.^1,2,3 He was the son of James Eli Harkins and Sadie Althea Pierce.¹ He died on 29 April 1988 in Youngsville, Warren County, Pennsylvania, at age 62.² He was buried in Berea Lutheran Cemetery, Pittsfield Township, Warren County, Pennsylvania.²

     Charles Lawrence Harkins served in the U.S. Army during World War II.²