Emma Cole1,2

b. December 1851, d. 23 October 1929
FatherGeorge Cole3
MotherPriscilla Dunn3
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Emma Cole was born in December 1851.1 She was the daughter of George Cole and Priscilla Dunn.3 She married Livingstone Benninghoff, son of George Benninghoff and Julia Ann Baney, on 19 July 1877 in Crawford County.2 She died on 23 October 1929 in Jamestown, New York, at age 77.3

Family

Livingstone Benninghoff b. 9 Apr 1852, d. 31 Oct 1908
Children

Citations

  1. [S152] 1900 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Crawford Co., West Mead Tp., Livingstone Benninghoff household, National Archives.
  2. [S208] Marriage announcement of Livingstone Benninghoff and Emma Cole, Evening Republican, Meadville, PA, 29 Jul 1877, Crawford County Historical Society, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Evening Republican.
  3. [S189] Unknown author, "Benninghoff File" (Benson Library, Meadville, PA). , information from marriage and obituary files. Hereinafter cited as "Benninghoff File."

George Cole1

     George Cole married Priscilla Dunn.1

Family

Priscilla Dunn
Child

Citations

  1. [S189] Unknown author, "Benninghoff File" (Benson Library, Meadville, PA). , information from marriage and obituary files. Hereinafter cited as "Benninghoff File."

Priscilla Dunn1

     Priscilla Dunn married George Cole.1

Family

George Cole
Child

Citations

  1. [S189] Unknown author, "Benninghoff File" (Benson Library, Meadville, PA). , information from marriage and obituary files. Hereinafter cited as "Benninghoff File."

May Belle Benninghoff1

b. October 1878
FatherLivingstone Benninghoff1 b. 9 Apr 1852, d. 31 Oct 1908
MotherEmma Cole1 b. Dec 1851, d. 23 Oct 1929
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     May Belle Benninghoff was born in October 1878.1 She was the daughter of Livingstone Benninghoff and Emma Cole.1 She married Frank E. Wallace on 31 October 1901 in Meadville, Crawford County.2

Citations

  1. [S152] 1900 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Crawford Co., West Mead Tp., Livingstone Benninghoff household, National Archives.
  2. [S208] Marriage announcement of May Belle Benninghoff and Frank E. Wallace of Jamestown, NY, Evening Republican, Meadville, PA, 31 Oct 1901, Crawford County Historical Society, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Evening Republican.
  3. [S211] George Benninghoff will, Crawford County Wills WB M:430, Registrar & Recorder's Office, Courthouse, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania . ((lists grandson Lawrence Wallace as beneficary)). Hereinafter cited as Crawford County Wills.

Frank E. Wallace1

ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Frank E. Wallace married May Belle Benninghoff, daughter of Livingstone Benninghoff and Emma Cole, on 31 October 1901 in Meadville, Crawford County.1

Family

May Belle Benninghoff b. Oct 1878
Child

Citations

  1. [S208] Marriage announcement of May Belle Benninghoff and Frank E. Wallace of Jamestown, NY, Evening Republican, Meadville, PA, 31 Oct 1901, Crawford County Historical Society, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Evening Republican.
  2. [S211] George Benninghoff will, Crawford County Wills WB M:430, Registrar & Recorder's Office, Courthouse, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania . Hereinafter cited as Crawford County Wills.

Lawrence Wallace1

FatherFrank E. Wallace1
MotherMay Belle Benninghoff2 b. Oct 1878
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Lawrence Wallace is the son of Frank E. Wallace and May Belle Benninghoff.1,2

Citations

  1. [S211] George Benninghoff will, Crawford County Wills WB M:430, Registrar & Recorder's Office, Courthouse, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania . Hereinafter cited as Crawford County Wills.
  2. [S211] George Benninghoff will, Crawford County Wills WB M:430, Registrar & Recorder's Office, Courthouse, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania . ((lists grandson Lawrence Wallace as beneficary)). Hereinafter cited as Crawford County Wills.

Lewis Morgan1

Family

Child

Citations

  1. [S208] Obituary of Charles E. Morgan, Evening Republican, Meadville, PA, 21 Jan 1907, p. 6, col. 4, Crawford County Historical Society, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania, (age 48). Hereinafter cited as Evening Republican.

George V. Benninghoff1

b. April 1881, d. 16 July 1944
FatherLivingstone Benninghoff1 b. 9 Apr 1852, d. 31 Oct 1908
MotherEmma Cole1 b. Dec 1851, d. 23 Oct 1929
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     George V. Benninghoff was born in April 1881.1 He was the son of Livingstone Benninghoff and Emma Cole.1 He married Anna Klohd on 19 April 1905 in Mahoning County, Ohio.2 He died on 16 July 1944 in Detroit, Michigan, at age 63.3,4

Citations

  1. [S152] 1900 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Crawford Co., West Mead Tp., Livingstone Benninghoff household, National Archives.
  2. [S1273] "Ohio, Marriages, 1800-1958," index, (https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XD63-YYR : accessed 16 Jun 2013), entry for George V. Benninghoff and Anna M. Klohd, 19 Apr 1905., viewed at FamilySearch (familysearch.org).
  3. [S15] Obituary of George Benninghoff, Tribune-Republican, Meaville, PA, 7 Aug. 1944, Crawford County Historical Society, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Tribune-Republican.
  4. [S189] Unknown author, "Benninghoff File" (Benson Library, Meadville, PA). , information from marriage and obituary files. Hereinafter cited as "Benninghoff File."

Anna Klohd1

ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Anna Klohd married George V. Benninghoff, son of Livingstone Benninghoff and Emma Cole, on 19 April 1905 in Mahoning County, Ohio.1

Family

George V. Benninghoff b. Apr 1881, d. 16 Jul 1944
Child

Citations

  1. [S1273] "Ohio, Marriages, 1800-1958," index, (https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XD63-YYR : accessed 16 Jun 2013), entry for George V. Benninghoff and Anna M. Klohd, 19 Apr 1905., viewed at FamilySearch (familysearch.org).

Norman Benninghoff1

FatherGeorge V. Benninghoff1 b. Apr 1881, d. 16 Jul 1944
MotherAnna Klohd2
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Norman Benninghoff was the son of George V. Benninghoff and Anna Klohd.1,2

Citations

  1. [S189] Unknown author, "Benninghoff File" (Benson Library, Meadville, PA). , information from marriage and obituary files. Hereinafter cited as "Benninghoff File."
  2. [S1273] "Ohio, Marriages, 1800-1958," index, (https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XD63-YYR : accessed 16 Jun 2013), entry for George V. Benninghoff and Anna M. Klohd, 19 Apr 1905., viewed at FamilySearch (familysearch.org).

Norman Henry Benninghoff1

b. 1 June 1882, d. 12 February 1942
FatherLivingstone Benninghoff1 b. 9 Apr 1852, d. 31 Oct 1908
MotherEmma Cole1 b. Dec 1851, d. 23 Oct 1929
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Norman Henry Benninghoff was born on 1 June 1882.1,2 He was the son of Livingstone Benninghoff and Emma Cole.1 He married Theresa Myers.3 He died on 12 February 1942 at age 59.3

Citations

  1. [S152] 1900 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, Crawford Co., West Mead Tp., Livingstone Benninghoff household, National Archives.
  2. [S973] World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917-1918 [database on-line], viewed at Ancestry.com (www.ancestry.com).
  3. [S189] Unknown author, "Benninghoff File" (Benson Library, Meadville, PA). , information from marriage and obituary files. Hereinafter cited as "Benninghoff File."

Theresa Myers1

ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Theresa Myers married Norman Henry Benninghoff, son of Livingstone Benninghoff and Emma Cole.1

Family

Norman Henry Benninghoff b. 1 Jun 1882, d. 12 Feb 1942
Children

Citations

  1. [S189] Unknown author, "Benninghoff File" (Benson Library, Meadville, PA). , information from marriage and obituary files. Hereinafter cited as "Benninghoff File."

Frank L. Benninghoff1

FatherNorman Henry Benninghoff1 b. 1 Jun 1882, d. 12 Feb 1942
MotherTheresa Myers1
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Frank L. Benninghoff is the son of Norman Henry Benninghoff and Theresa Myers.1 He married Velma Tyler on 25 August 1930 in First Baptist Church, Meadville, Crawford County.2

Citations

  1. [S189] Unknown author, "Benninghoff File" (Benson Library, Meadville, PA). , information from marriage and obituary files. Hereinafter cited as "Benninghoff File."
  2. [S15] Marriage announcement of Frank L. Benninghoff of Meadville and Velma Tyler, Tribune-Republican, Meaville, PA, 26 Aug 1930, p. 6, col. 8,, Crawford County Historical Society, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Tribune-Republican.
  3. [S12] Crawford County Marriage License, marriage license of Theresa A. Benninghoff and WilliamL. Allman, Registrar & Recorder's Office, Courthouse, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Crawford Co. (PA) Marriage License.

Velma Tyler1

ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Velma Tyler married Frank L. Benninghoff, son of Norman Henry Benninghoff and Theresa Myers, on 25 August 1930 in First Baptist Church, Meadville, Crawford County.2

Citations

  1. [S15] 26 Aug 1930, p. 6, col. 8, marriage announcement of Frank L. Benninghoff of Meadville and Velma Tyler, Tribune-Republican, Meaville, PA, Crawford County Historical Society, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Tribune-Republican.
  2. [S15] Marriage announcement of Frank L. Benninghoff of Meadville and Velma Tyler, Tribune-Republican, Meaville, PA, 26 Aug 1930, p. 6, col. 8,, Crawford County Historical Society, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Tribune-Republican.
  3. [S12] Crawford County Marriage License, marriage license of Theresa A. Benninghoff and WilliamL. Allman, Registrar & Recorder's Office, Courthouse, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Crawford Co. (PA) Marriage License.

Theresa A. Benninghoff1

FatherFrank L. Benninghoff1
MotherVelma Tyler1
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Theresa A. Benninghoff is the daughter of Frank L. Benninghoff and Velma Tyler.1 She married William L. Allman on 19 October 1953.2

Citations

  1. [S12] Crawford County Marriage License, marriage license of Theresa A. Benninghoff and WilliamL. Allman, Registrar & Recorder's Office, Courthouse, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Crawford Co. (PA) Marriage License.
  2. [S12] Crawford County Marriage License, marriage license of Theresa A. Benninghoff and William L. Allman, Registrar & Recorder's Office, Courthouse, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Crawford Co. (PA) Marriage License.

William L. Allman1

ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     William L. Allman married Theresa A. Benninghoff, daughter of Frank L. Benninghoff and Velma Tyler, on 19 October 1953.1

Citations

  1. [S12] Crawford County Marriage License, marriage license of Theresa A. Benninghoff and William L. Allman, Registrar & Recorder's Office, Courthouse, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Crawford Co. (PA) Marriage License.

Henry Benninghoff1

FatherNorman Henry Benninghoff1 b. 1 Jun 1882, d. 12 Feb 1942
MotherTheresa Myers1
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Henry Benninghoff is the son of Norman Henry Benninghoff and Theresa Myers.1

Citations

  1. [S189] Unknown author, "Benninghoff File" (Benson Library, Meadville, PA). , information from marriage and obituary files. Hereinafter cited as "Benninghoff File."

Raymond Benninghoff1

d. before 1942
FatherNorman Henry Benninghoff b. 1 Jun 1882, d. 12 Feb 1942
MotherTheresa Myers
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Raymond Benninghoff was the son of Norman Henry Benninghoff and Theresa Myers. He died before 1942 since he was not mentioned in his father's obituary.1

Citations

  1. [S189] Unknown author, "Benninghoff File" (Benson Library, Meadville, PA). , information from marriage and obituary files. Hereinafter cited as "Benninghoff File."

Nancy Jane Hogan1

b. 1 September 1858
FatherJames McKee Hogan1
MotherPriscilla Sheppard1
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Nancy Jane Hogan was born on 1 September 1858 in Monterey, Pennsylvania.1 She was the daughter of James McKee Hogan and Priscilla Sheppard.1 She married George Edward Benninghoff, son of George Benninghoff and Julia Ann Baney, on 1 January 1880 in Monterey, Pennsylvania.1,2

Family

George Edward Benninghoff b. 10 Feb 1855
Children

Citations

  1. [S142] John W. Jordan LL.D Genealogical and Personal History of the Allegheny Valley, Pennsylvania (New York: Lewis Historical Publishing Co., 1913). Hereinafter cited as Jordan's Allegheny Valley.
  2. [S208] Marriage announcement of Dr. G.E. Benninghoff and Miss Nannie Hogan, Evening Republican, Meadville, PA, 25 Jun 1880, p. 3, col. 3, Crawford County Historical Society, Meadville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Evening Republican.

James McKee Hogan1

     James McKee Hogan married Priscilla Sheppard.1

Family

Priscilla Sheppard
Child

Citations

  1. [S142] John W. Jordan LL.D Genealogical and Personal History of the Allegheny Valley, Pennsylvania (New York: Lewis Historical Publishing Co., 1913). Hereinafter cited as Jordan's Allegheny Valley.

Priscilla Sheppard1

     Priscilla Sheppard married James McKee Hogan.1

Family

James McKee Hogan
Child

Citations

  1. [S142] John W. Jordan LL.D Genealogical and Personal History of the Allegheny Valley, Pennsylvania (New York: Lewis Historical Publishing Co., 1913). Hereinafter cited as Jordan's Allegheny Valley.

Walter Garrett Benninghoff1

b. 1 September 1887, d. 28 March 1903
FatherGeorge Edward Benninghoff1 b. 10 Feb 1855
MotherNancy Jane Hogan1 b. 1 Sep 1858
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Walter Garrett Benninghoff was born on 1 September 1887.1 He was the son of George Edward Benninghoff and Nancy Jane Hogan.1 He died on 28 March 1903 in Bradford, McKean County, Pennsylvania, at age 15.2,1 He was buried in Oak Hill Cemetery, Bradford, McKean County, Pennsylvania.2

Citations

  1. [S142] John W. Jordan LL.D Genealogical and Personal History of the Allegheny Valley, Pennsylvania (New York: Lewis Historical Publishing Co., 1913). Hereinafter cited as Jordan's Allegheny Valley.
  2. [S361] Oibituary of Walter Benninghoff, Oil City Semi-Weekly Derrick, Oil City, PA, 31 Mar 1903/3 Apr 1903, Heritage Room, Oil City Library, Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania. Hereinafter cited as Semi-Weekly Derrick.

Julia Benninghoff1

b. 3 September 1893
FatherGeorge Edward Benninghoff1 b. 10 Feb 1855
MotherNancy Jane Hogan1 b. 1 Sep 1858
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Julia Benninghoff was born on 3 September 1893.1 She was the daughter of George Edward Benninghoff and Nancy Jane Hogan.1 She married Robert Horth Cornell on 24 September 1914.2
     Julia Benninghoff was attending school in 1912 in Washington, D.C..1

Citations

  1. [S142] John W. Jordan LL.D Genealogical and Personal History of the Allegheny Valley, Pennsylvania (New York: Lewis Historical Publishing Co., 1913). Hereinafter cited as Jordan's Allegheny Valley.
  2. [S142] John W. Jordan LL.D Genealogical and Personal History of the Allegheny Valley, Pennsylvania (New York: Lewis Historical Publishing Co., 1913), (unknown page number). Hereinafter cited as Jordan's Allegheny Valley.

Robert Horth Cornell1

ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Robert Horth Cornell married Julia Benninghoff, daughter of George Edward Benninghoff and Nancy Jane Hogan, on 24 September 1914.1

Citations

  1. [S142] John W. Jordan LL.D Genealogical and Personal History of the Allegheny Valley, Pennsylvania (New York: Lewis Historical Publishing Co., 1913), (unknown page number). Hereinafter cited as Jordan's Allegheny Valley.

Robert Horth Cornell Jr1

FatherRobert Horth Cornell1
MotherJulia Benninghoff2 b. 3 Sep 1893
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Robert Horth Cornell Jr is the son of Robert Horth Cornell and Julia Benninghoff.1,2

Citations

  1. [S142] John W. Jordan LL.D Genealogical and Personal History of the Allegheny Valley, Pennsylvania (New York: Lewis Historical Publishing Co., 1913), (unknown page number). Hereinafter cited as Jordan's Allegheny Valley.
  2. [S142] John W. Jordan LL.D Genealogical and Personal History of the Allegheny Valley, Pennsylvania (New York: Lewis Historical Publishing Co., 1913). Hereinafter cited as Jordan's Allegheny Valley.

Nancy Jane Cornell1

FatherRobert Horth Cornell1
MotherJulia Benninghoff b. 3 Sep 1893
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Nancy Jane Cornell is the daughter of Robert Horth Cornell and Julia Benninghoff.1

Citations

  1. [S142] John W. Jordan LL.D Genealogical and Personal History of the Allegheny Valley, Pennsylvania (New York: Lewis Historical Publishing Co., 1913), (unknown page number). Hereinafter cited as Jordan's Allegheny Valley.

George Cornell1

FatherRobert Horth Cornell1
MotherJulia Benninghoff b. 3 Sep 1893
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     George Cornell is the son of Robert Horth Cornell and Julia Benninghoff.1

Citations

  1. [S142] John W. Jordan LL.D Genealogical and Personal History of the Allegheny Valley, Pennsylvania (New York: Lewis Historical Publishing Co., 1913), (unknown page number). Hereinafter cited as Jordan's Allegheny Valley.

Lucy Cornell1

FatherRobert Horth Cornell1
MotherJulia Benninghoff b. 3 Sep 1893
ChartsDescendants of John Baney
Descendants of Frederick Benninghoff
     Lucy Cornell is the daughter of Robert Horth Cornell and Julia Benninghoff.1

Citations

  1. [S142] John W. Jordan LL.D Genealogical and Personal History of the Allegheny Valley, Pennsylvania (New York: Lewis Historical Publishing Co., 1913), (unknown page number). Hereinafter cited as Jordan's Allegheny Valley.

Lebbeus Marion Strong1

b. 29 August 1835, d. 1918
FatherSylvester Strong1
MotherMargaret English1
Lebbus Marion Strong
     Lebbeus Marion Strong was born on 29 August 1835.1 He was the son of Sylvester Strong and Margaret English.1 He married Cynthia Elizabeth Morrison, daughter of Zephaniah Morrison and Amanda Northrop, on 18 September 1858.1 He died in 1918.2 He and Cynthia Elizabeth Morrison were buried in Kinzua Cemetery, Kinzua, Kinzua Township, Warren County.3
     Lebbeus Marion Strong and Cynthia Elizabeth Morrison lived in Hamilton Township, McKean County, Pennsylvania, where Lebbeus was involved in the timber business. In 1880, his occupation was recorded as bark peeler.4,5 He and Cynthia Elizabeth Morrison were living in Kinzua Township, Warren County, Pennsylvania, in 1910 with Lebbeus' brother Edward Strong.6

Family

Cynthia Elizabeth Morrison b. 6 Sep 1840, d. 1931
Children

Citations

  1. [S94] File Card Collection, Warren County Historical Society, Warren, Pennsylvania, Family records from Layton M. and Ella (Wheeler) Strong Bible.
  2. [S91] Warren County Historical Society, Gravestone Inscriptions from the Kinzue Cemetery (n.p.: n.pub.), Lebbeus Strong. Hereinafter cited as Kinzue Cemetery Gravestones.
  3. [S91] Warren County Historical Society, Gravestone Inscriptions from the Kinzue Cemetery (n.p.: n.pub.), Lebbeus and Cynthia Strong. Hereinafter cited as Kinzue Cemetery Gravestones.
  4. [S151] 1880 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, McKean Co., Hamilton Tp., Lebbus Strong household, National Archives, (Lebbus Strong, 45, PA, bark peeler; Cynthia, 40; Layton, 19, bark peeler; Clarissis, 17; Jean, 11; Margie, 9; Zephaniah, 6; Maud, 2; Peter Dempsey, 48, bark peeler; Jesse Snyder, 24, bark peeler; Sara Draffenbacher, 14, servant).
  5. [S152] 1900 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, McKean Co., Hamilton Tp., Lebbus Strong household, National Archives, (L.M. Strong, Aug. 1835, m. 42y; Cynthia E., Sep 1840, 9child/6lvg; Leonard J., May 1881).
  6. [S207] 1910 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, McKean Co., Kinzua Tp., Edward Strong household, National Archives, (Edward Strong, 62, PA/MA/PA, md41y, laborer, stone work; Jane E., 67, MA/VT/MA; Lebbus M., 76, PA/MA/PA, md52y, brother; Cynthia E., 70, PA/PA/PA, 10child/6lvg, sister-in-law).
  7. [S213] Obituary of Layton Strong, Warren Evening Times, Warren, PA, 9 Oct. 1922. Hereinafter cited as Warren Evening Times.
  8. [S485] Marriage License, license of John T. Lamb and Clarissa A. Strong, Registrar & Recorder's Office, Courthouse, Warren, Pennsylvania.
  9. [S91] Warren County Historical Society, Gravestone Inscriptions from the Kinzue Cemetery (n.p.: n.pub.), Regina C. Strong. Hereinafter cited as Kinzue Cemetery Gravestones.
  10. [S151] 1880 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, McKean Co., Hamilton Tp., Lebbus Strong household, National Archives.
  11. [S152] 1900 U.S. Census, Pennsylvania, McKean Co., Hamilton Tp., Lebbus Strong household, National Archives.